Search:     Advanced search
Browse by category:
Contact Us

Views: 2130


Assalaamu 'alaykum,

In a book by Abu Ammaar Yasir Qadhi

Chapter 11 of An Introduction to the Sciences of the Qur’aan, pp. 184-202 (1999), Al-Hidaayah Publishing and Distribution.

 It mentions that: `These Raawis learnt the qiraa’a from their Imaam, and each preserved some of the variations of the recitation of the Qaaree. Sometimes, the Qaaree taught different qira’aat to each Raawi. Hafs quoted ‘Aasim as saying that the qiraa’a he taught him was that of Aboo ‘Abd al-Rahmaan as-Sulamee (d. 70 A.H.) from ‘Alee ibn Abee Taalib, while the one that he taught Aboo Bakr ibn ‘Iyaash (i.e., Shu’ba, the other Raawi of ‘Aasim) was that of Zirr ibn Hubaysh (d. 83 A.H.) from Ibn Mas’ood.  449 Wohaibee, p. 106`

can you clarify what this means?


Wa alaikum assalaam wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatuh,

This is a singular transmission (Aahad) in which Hafs complained to his Sheikh, Imam ‘Aasim that he found that there were differences in the way he and Shu’bah read, and Imam ‘Aasim explained that he gave them each a way he learned from two different Taab’ieen, who took from two different companions.  This is found in Ghaayah an-Naahaya fee Tabaqaat Al-Qurraa’ by Imam Ibn al-Jazaree in the biography of Hafs. 

Besides this source, we have many books which Imam Al-Jazaree relied upon as sources in An-Nashr to compile and prove the authenticity of the over 1000 turuq he compiled for the Muslim nation in this work. 

The single transmission is one of the few, if not the only information we have of which riwaayah an Imam of the qira’at taught from which of his teachers. 

For example, we know that Naafi’ read to over 70 of the taabi’een, but we do not know which riwaayah or tareeq he took from which.  It was not documented.  We know who Naafi’ recited to, we know who ‘Aasim recited to etc, but we do not know which tareeq each took from which of the Imam’s or taab’i above them in the sanad.  This is not something which have access to on the whole, except in this case we have information indicating which taab’I Aasim took which way he taught two of his students. 

This information is therefore unique, but we cannot access this for others, so when we state Hafs read to ‘Aasim and he read to the various named taab’ieen and they to named sahabah, we do not differentiate the ways for each.  It is not possible to do for others and not done by any scholar in the past.

And Allah knows best

Others in this Category
document Is there a sunnah way of finishing a recitation.?
document In Part 1 of Tajweed Rules in English there is a chart detailing the chain of transmission for Hafs 'an Asim. At the level of the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, some of them are mentioned more than once.
document I heard some people say taa when it has a vowel it should not have any hems...
document Please, What is madda and types of madda? explain in the types.
document Can I ask, how would you know when to do ghunnah for double kasra, double thumma and double fatha?
document Why in Surah al Fatihah in the ayah that reads "Ihdinas-siratal mustaqeem" in Hafs do we not read the "noon" with the "alif" that is immediately after it?
document In the Indo-Pak script, the word in Surah Rum Ayat 54, "Dha'fin" has a Dhammah with a line on first letter "Dhaad"
document In Warsh which surahs do you have to do taqleel whether you read madd badal with 2/4/6 counts.
document In Al-Bazzi and Qunbul, in surah Qiyaamah, Ayah number 1, the alif after the first laam has a saakin. Does this mean it is read "La Uqsimu" instead of "Laa Uqsimu". Is there any other places where this happens as well?
document Is it correct to say the Name of Allah should have a fatha not a dagger alif?
document When reciting the letter "saad" with either a fatha, kasra, or damma, do the lips also move or only the tongue rises up?
document To make a letter tafkheem or heavy it says to elevate the posterior tongue area to the roof of the mouth. Do we elevate the tongue as we say a letter or do we first elevate the tongue to the roof of the mouth then say the letter?